Most damage disputes start with the same problem: nobody can prove what condition the car left in. A rigorous inspection settles the question.
Why the inspection is your best evidence
A customer who insists "the scratch was already there" can only be contradicted by a dated, signed document. Without one, the agency absorbs the cost or loses the customer. With one, the conversation becomes factual.
The pickup checklist
- Bodywork: bumpers, doors, wings, roof, bonnet, boot. Note every scratch, dent or chip.
- Glass, mirrors and lights: chips, cracks, broken parts.
- Tyres and rims: wear, rim damage, spare wheel and jack.
- Interior: upholstery, dashboard, cleanliness, smells, mats.
- Equipment: warning triangle, vest, vehicle papers, spare key.
- Dashboard: mileage and fuel level.
Photos: dated, plentiful, systematic
Always take the same views in the same order: the four corners of the car, each side, the interior, the dashboard and every existing defect up close. A consistent series is more convincing than a few random shots. Photos should be time-stamped and attached to the rental, not lost in a phone gallery.
The customer's signature, every time
Have the customer sign the pickup report before handing over the keys, and sign the return report in person. A return done "without the customer" opens the door to later disputes.
Compare pickup and return
At return, run the same checklist and compare line by line with pickup. Document any difference immediately, with photos, before the customer leaves. What to withhold from the deposit is then discussed on facts (see the guide on deposits).
Doing it from the phone
In the Carentfy mobile app, the inspection is done on the spot: photos attached to the contract, damage noted and stored with the rental history. You can try it for free.
Ready to digitize your agency?
Start the 30-day free trial. No credit card. Cancel anytime.